As one of the judges, I'd like to offer a few words…
Firstly, thank you to all those who entered; I enjoyed the judging process and was delighted to see so many high-quality games. Several times, I found myself having to stop enjoying myself so that I could get on with judging the rest of the games!
I was very impressed with the entries. Many of the games were presented very professionally; clearly the winners and many of those games that came to the top of the shortlist are either ready for, or are very close to, being put up for sponsorship (or other commercialisation), so well done.
Picking the top three was a very tough call and, as Irock stated, there was some debate required amongst the judges to finalise the winners.
For those of you in the 'Games we also liked' list, you were so close (really, very close), but we had to draw the line at three winners. I genuinely enjoyed playing most of the games; too many to mention in fact!
For those entrants who have not received a mention, don't be down-hearted (or offended); if we had mentioned all the games we liked, it would have been a very long list!
If you didn't enter the competition, then do try to play the games and learn from them. Make notes about what you do and do not like, and also have a look at the entry page in the forums for each game; many of them have discussions containing useful information about the development process, including ideas, problems, successes, etc.