9
« on: June 07, 2011, 02:02:37 pm »
The controller is interesting, but I'm a bit worried about some things.
1) The Wiimote looks like it would still have some gimmick uses, but otherwise it seems like it will be obsolete. Except of course for backwards compatibility, like how you need a GameCube controller to play GameCube games on the Wii. So RIP Wii MotionPlus. Or maybe they plan on having the Wii Remote + Nunchuck + Wii MotionPlus live on as a second controller type for the Wii U, which would be a great inconvenience, especially for people who don't already have the Wii controller family.
2) Yeah, you can play games on the controller without the TV. Yeah, some games can use the screen for something important. But you can't do both with the same game. That means the only games you can play without a TV would be the ones where the developers couldn't come up with a good idea for how to use the controller screen. It would be a nice way to prevent screenlooking in what would otherwise be split-screen games, but again, that precludes any other use for the controller screen, and what does that mean for your HDTV?
3) The controller looks pretty bulky. Nintendo has been pretty good about making their controllers comfortable in the past though. I never was good at holding the DS one-handed in order to use the stylus, so I'm a bit worried about how that will feel with this controller.
4) The button and stick placement seems a little weird. I'm glad it has two shoulder buttons on each end, but the lower shoulder buttons don't look right. The sticks look weird being placed right above the buttons and D-pad, but I guess it doesn't matter since you can't use the D-pad and left stick at the same time.
I think the concept will work really nice, but it seems like they're leaving the Wiimote + Nunchuck behind, which was the most iconic thing about the Wii and still had a lot of untapped potential. I mean, we've still got the new Zelda that has yet to come out, where you have full control over Link's sword, but now the Wii U is going in a completely different direction where, oh joy, you have a menu on the controller. Perhaps there will still be lots of Wiimote + Nunchuck games, but the W+N uses won't be any different than the current gen except for developer creativity. For a Wii "sequel", it seems to deviate too much.
Now, things I'm completely happy about. I'm glad it's getting a graphics boost, and I'm glad Nintendo is planning a better online system. I'm glad the controller has a full assortment of buttons so that multi-platform games can be ported without needing some gimmick motion to simulate a button press.
I'm done with my rant.